Really awkward upper-half, but overall there is something I really like about this shot.

Oooh...elegant and sort of weird. I like it.

her arm and shoulder look really wierd... but I see it in the top 5

This is awful. I could point out a bunch of stuff that I don't like but I'll just focus on the biggest things. Her arm looks dislocated and her knee is just jutting out of her skirt for no reason (I usually call it the "penis knee". See Samantha C11's Natural Disasters shot for another example)

it's quite manly, isnt it?

...she put in werque with this one!

This is so weird, I cant