Really underrated by the judges. Nigel's an idiot for letting his shadow in the shot but I do think it kind of works in this case. Gives it a bit of a Film Noir-y vibe for me.
Im still not sold on Catherine, this is the best shot of her so far (IMO) but I dont think its that great, I think the angle looks really wierd and I dont like her face
Her upper half just looks sick(in a good way). I love all of the angles and elegance. She also looks 7 ft tall here. I think she looks a little strained in the eyes and the shadow that the hat cast on her face pulls it down, but this is still a good shot.