This is not as bad as it was made out to be. It is better than Aimee's, but I do think she should have been in the bottom two for this shot alone. I do think she was shooting herself in the foot with her outfit at panel but the judges overreacted. Lisa wore a headband to panel during Cycle 5 and nobody complained about it then.
She was eliminated because her drive was questioned (and it should be, considering she wants to be a make-up artist now). Not for the headband or photo.
I think this picture is nowhere near as bad as they made it out to be, but the shoots(If she wasn't an editing victim) were painful to watch. And from the show, she kinda acted like she was there to have fun rather than becoming a model. Still love her, though.