I actually think this photo is gorgeous. As a whole and Aimee. She definitely should have been sent home.

R&B was one of the hardest topic. I mean rock, pop, punk, folk, house and country are easier because you can work with a lot of stereotypes. Aimee should of stayed while Claire should have left but I love Claire as well...

She had one of the easiest sets and she did nothing with it. She could of acted like a diva and been so dramatic. Lauren had the hardest set. She had NOTHING to work with.

i think its a hot photo... tyra was being dumb

No matter how bad this photo was to the judges she shouldn't of been sent home based on her previous performance, she was one of the better girls this cycle. As for the photo, I personally don't think it's that bad, the sultry look she has in her eye is very R&B to me. Not every female R&B singer is an over-the-top diva bitch you know Tyra.

this pic is not great but she looks beautiful anyway. she shouldn't have been eliminated.

guys the name of the show is America's Next Top Model not America's Most Beautiful Girl. you can take any girl out of a mall and tell her to look beautiful in front of the camera and she will deliver. it takes a true model to deliver a shot that either encorporates the theme of the shoot or sell whatever she is selling even if she is not inspired by her set because she needs to be the photographer's inspiration.

stacey ann and dominique looked more mall-ish than aimee............

i wasnt trying to say she looks mallish i was saying that beautiful and pretty does not cut it so just saying that she looks beautful is not a valid reason to stay

I agree steagle just about any so so model can look pretty in a picture.It takes a great model to actually rock a photoshoot and come out with something actually stylish,inspiring and dynamic.Aimee does look really pretty here but appearently that just didn't cut it.

true, but I feel that if you can't work the theme at least try to look good; dominique didn't look like a folk singer and didn't look pretty, stacey anne looked overposed, boring, and just kinda odd

no born, dominique's only problem was that she was modeling with 1/3 of her body at a time, she did embrace the whole "leave my mother earth alone" part of folk.

I felt that her shot just didn't embody folk music, her angry stare just didn't work with the environment or music

^ Agreed, the judges complained that Aimee didn't get her genre but Dominique was also called out on not getting Folk music but that it was a pretty photo anyway. Uhhhh.....this photo is pretty too, why was Aimee sent home over Domanique?

I really like this photo....Claire should have been eliminated

this is actually a good shot, she looks beautiful

Claire started to show her true colors that week.

agree with epo.

I don't think Aimee should have gone home, neither do I think Claire should. Domanique had the weakest picture, that weak the judges showed favoratism, which is slightly bias. Claire could have done better, yes, but she still has a strong and stunning face many models strive to have. Claire had a bad week which led to the belive that she was not versatile enough, which is untrue. Claire and Aimee could have gone way farther in the competition if it werent for favoratism, but thats just my honest opinion.

or more people liked aimee and claire so when they started weakening people began to use dominique as a scape goat. happens everytime the fan favorite gets the boot, Whit was scape goated for Anya and Fatima was scape goated for Amis (more in the myspace groups then on here).