swt....i tot we were talking abt cycle 11..........not whitney or anya weakness and strength............if tyra replace the judges wif all of u....one word 2 describe......CATASTROPHE....i tink ANTM rating will increase

A very pretty photo, but not Covergirl at all.

Even though I don't like this photo and I still wish Analeigh won, I am happy for her. Mckey was bland but I did like some of her photos. But I think Analeigh deserved it MUCH more than her.

Favorite of the week. Although none of the pictures this week never worked for Covergirl.

^ This was the worst cycle for CG shots, other than C8 and C3

uughh......ok......mckey is suitable for beauty campaign,high fashion,victoria's secret or ashley paige(any swimsuit designers),sports illustrated,editotial and runway....majorie is suitable for high fashion,editorial and maybe commercial without speaking(chanel,lancome).....analeigh is suitable for avant grade,beauty campaign,commercial,high fashion and runway(victoria secret)...sam is for anything tat exclude runway...tat is my opinion...hw bout ur guys?

mckey is suitable for beauty, high fashion. her hips are much too large for victoria's secret or swimsuits, and her runway is mediocre at best. she looks like a man clunking around. and her commercial was dull. it reminded me of the commercial challenge at the first few episodes that hannah won. she never changed.

marjorie is suitable for high fashion, beauty, commercial, runway, and swimsuits, but she's not a vs type to me.

analeigh is suitable for high fashion, beauty, commercial, and runway. definitely a vs girl.

sam can do high fashion, commercial, swimsuits, and runways (which she proved in the final runway when she whooped mckey's size 37 ass. her commercial was passable as well.

McKey belongs in a Clinique/Estee Lauder ad, Marjorie (if she got over her stupid nerves) could pull of something Prada-esque, Analeigh NEEDS to be a Victoria's Secret girl and Samantha could do high fashion/editorial if she got her act together. And whoever said McKey could do Victoria's Secret is crazy. Victoria's Secret is all about feminity and flowy hair, McKey would look like a man clunking down the runway.

^ You HONESTLY think Marj could do runway David?

^YES, jesse_dillon, I HONESTLY BELIEVE MARJORIE CAN DO RUNWAY. she's not some ridiculous stomper, but she has a soft step and grace in her walk which was evident in that ugly bank fashion show.

Her walk in Jeremy Scott's show was laughable. People were laughing at her. Marjorie will never do runway.

people were NOT laughing at her. her walk is dainty and chic. not an average runway walk, but not bad at all. and she certainly has the height. marjorie has a future in runway modeling.

Okay, you keep telling yourself that david18. Watch the Jeremy Scott show again. The girls that did fabulously were Sheena, Joslyn, Analeigh and Clark. Lauren Brie's was awkward but worked. david18 you're not the only one on these boards who have experience in the fashion industry. Marjorie would get laughed out of any legitimate runway audition. Does she have the potential to fix it? Yes. But there is nothing chic about something THAT awkward.

runfiercely, since when did i say that everyone in this board is a failure in fashion knowledge? i don't KNOW these members to make any sort of assumption like that. don't put words in my mouth.

I didn't! you misread it, man! It's a statement on my part. "you're not the only one who has experience..." is a statement on my part! simple as that dude! But seriously david18 as much as I enjoy our arguments, I don't want to get in a fight! so I'm going to drop it here! I hope you can too.

runfiercely, i'm not fighting with you. i'm just explaining myself. my fighting techniques usually involve CAPS and many . i'm not mad or anything, i'm just clarifying. and i'm sorry i misread your comment.

hey it's okay dude. we seem to disagree on a lot of stuff, don't we? which is good because without our opinions the Whitney/Fatima world balance would be thrown off. lol

"Whooped McKey's size 37 ass"
^LOL I LOVED THAT!

Whitney-
Promo- I actually liked short hair on her and I saw some potential.
Pre-Show- Her face was extremely interesting in her pre-show picture to me. That brown hair edged her out IMO.
Week 1- Her picture shocked the hell out of me. @David, its not so much that Brita looked worried, its more that she looked OLD, especially considering the styling.
Week 2- This sux. I'm not sure if I'm on Whitney's side with this one, but that lingirie she wore looked extremely uncomfortable.
Makeover- She's sexy, but more of a playboy sexy, unfortunately.
Week 3- This isn't HF. It looks more like a commercial ad for meat. However, it still easily beats out alot of the girls that week.
Week 4- This is just disgusting. It still creeps me out to this day.
Week 5- Amazing. That facial expression is just.... AMAZING
Week 6- I like this. The adult sonogram thing she did was extremely artistic and that was the point. Good job Whitney.
Week 7- Giant little girl in her momma's heels.
Week 8- Best CG commercial for me. I still don't get why she was in the bottom two over Anya or Dominique. I think they WANTED their winner to be in the bottom two so many times.
Week 9- Ouch. Terrible angle. Even though Kat's was worse, Kat is so much more HF. Bad elimination.
Week 10- This is pretty, but just not good enough. This is where I would've pulled the Whit x Fat bottom two TBH.
CG Commercial- All I remember is that she blew Anya and Fatima out of the park.
CG Photo- This is STUNNING.
Finals- She had a rather unfair advantage with the dresses. She stood out, but not for the right reasons. She didn't look like a model on the runway, even though she did work it.
Overall- As you can see with previous evaluations, Whitney is obviously a commercial girl. She is just too inconsistent to be a top model. And like it was stated before, she's too small for plus-sized. Normal sized girls aren't really big in the fashion world. Also, as a side note, having an open mouth in every frame can make you predictable.

Anya-
Promo- She's pretty and there is potential. Stands out more than others like Aimee or Allison(the former being too pretty pretty, the latter TOTALLY hiding her interesting face behind her hat).
Pre-Show- There's def. some HF we can squeeze out of this girl. I didn't expect it to come out so soon, though.
Week 1- Oh my GOD the pose. This is COUTURE. Take notes.
Week 2- The claw is a little strange, but the FACE sells it.
Makeover- Eww. The hair makes her look so old. And I just did not get her face here.
Week 3- The styling is just all wrong. She shines right through it, fortunately. I'm not a big fan of her shot.
Week 4- Its an extremely cute commercial pose. However, the neck extension and positioning with the fierce face took it to the next level. Squint isn't really needed, but it would've taken it further.
Week 5- AAAAH I love this shot. Its like art + couture to me.
Week 6- This is extremely artistic and just plain FIERCE. She def. rocked it.
Week 7- This is extremely cute. She could've turned it out better like Lauren, though.
Week 8- Oh gawd no. Commercial just isn't her thing.
Week 9- Tyra's photography ruins the shot. Aside from that, she slam dunked it.
Week 10- AMAZING. Even her accidents are fierce!!!!!!
CG Commercial- SHE looked like a barbie doll. Perfect. But the commercial, OMG.
CG Picture- This is crap. I'm sorry.
Finals- She had an unfair disadvantage with some of the outfits. However, she def. stood out with her LOOK.
Overall- Anya's the epitome of high fashion. Of course, she can't do nothin' commercial, but that doesn't stop her from being one of the strongest girls ANTM has ever had. She just screams model from head to toe and demonstrates extraordinary talent and versatility.

So overall, I don't even think it comes close. Anya obviously beats Whitney to the ground. However, ANTM has become alot more of a commercial modeling/personality contest since cycle 9, and it has ALWAYS been about making the less obvious choice, so w/e. Anya is successful anyway.

i like to believe i have a way with words . thought i'd throw that number in there since so many mckey lovers just love bringing up saleisha's hip size (which is actually getting smaller! just checked the site and they are listed as 35.5. half an inch. not bad.) but mckey's really fit, so i don't know how she'll lose the inches.

McKey tends to take over the last comments page alot, but def. not for the right reasons . I wonder why no one can really remember her....