She HAD the competetion in her hands. I honestly think she would've won. But since the bull shot, she was declining..rapidly. Thank god..lol

BIG NOSE

its not that she has a big nose but that angle makes her look like she has a big nose. anya, natasha and aj also look like they have big noses in this angle

It's not big at all, I actually prefer thsi to eugena's shot

She looks constipated.

I Think This Shot Is Better Than Caridees And She Would Have Won If She Had A Better Covergirl picture Then Hers

ChaChaDiva101, why all the hate on CariDee? It doesn't change the fact that she won.

bcuz caridees personality just gets on my nerves she is very rude and she is a follower bcuz on the show she did talk to melrose but when eugenas ugly ass said something caridee followed her like a little baby

I really do not like this, her and natasha probably would have won, but they probably do not want to let down covergirl with a bad picture

why would this photo be better then caridees, CariDee's was so much better!

I Think What ChaChaDiva101 Is Trying To Say Is That Caridee Had A Fun Personatlity But From Time To Time It Was A Rude And She Made Tons Of Rude Remarks To People Also Your Right Starburst That It Doesnt Change The Fact She One But If Thats The Case Then You Should Go To Jaslenes Saleishas And Whitneys Album Bcuz Theres Tons Of Hate There

My GOD this is one of the worst CGs ever. Her lips are so so so small here and the product was LIPSTICK. Eugena's and Caridee's were so much better, but thank GOD they picked Mel over George Washington.

LOVE IT STILL

It could be an ad for contact lenses for sure, though. Her eyes look great.

Caridee has an stronger portfolio and more consistant photos, there´s no doubt about it

I understand the jaw tension that the judges described, but this works very well as a CoverGirl ad.

I refuse to believe that this was Melrose's best CG shot. Had her shot been perfect, there would have been no way that she could have lose. Her runway was very strong, so if her picture was great, there would have been no excuse for having Caridee win.

Exactly, but her shot was worse than Cari's, so she lost. I agree that there would have been no way Cari would have won.

i agree davew18. i don't think this was her best shot of all either. and cari-should-o-dee soooo didn't have a stronger portfolio than melrose, nor was she more consistant.

Fuck Caridee's portfolio was way better than Melrose's!!! The model stereotype, the hair wars, the circus freak, the sexy scary, the novel cover, the windtunnel and the matador pics are so much better than Mel's!