The face is pretty but dead, the body looks uncomfortable. The photo does not work as a whole, but it's not something that justifies an elimination. I don't see a TON of potential in Kimberly but I think she'd make a great commercial/upper end catalogue model, I would have kept her to the Gargoyles shoot.
To me there is just something off about Kimberly's face. Her eyes are stunning and her jawline (and ears Tyra!) are lovely though. Maybe her mouth is too rabbity?
I see the Taylor Swift comparison, sort of, but I think Kim's a whole lot prettier. Taylor seems to look smooshed and pinched all the time, but Kim's eyes just draw you in.