Mckey smile is stay in my mind with a long time

nice sexy smile

She looks so sweet in this picture

love this to death

her lips look like sausage.

LOve it!!!! flawless and elegant

2nd best covergirl picture ever after caridee.....

I think this picture is B.E.A.U.T.I.F.U.L!!! I picked her to win right away

I always thought this picture was kind of repulsive. The lips look kinda nasty, and she has this creepy rapist smile.

I always loved Mckey. She was the most consistent girl who won, just like Naima Mora, Nicole Fox and Nicole Linkletter.

I can't deny my love for this picture. It's stellar but CoverGirl? No. Congrats anyway for improving in her commercial, her kiss was the best but Analeigh suits CG and Seventeen better and has a great walk unlike McKey.

i dont like it at all... but I love Mckey

Meh. I don't like it as much as Aneleigh's. It's pretty, yes, and I love her eyes but... it's just sort of clumsy in the angles and the strap of her tang top just barely sticking out there. Her hair looks a bit blocky to me. I don't like it so much. But hey, that's just me maybe. I like McKey, though. I wasn't too disappointed that she won.

I like McKey but this looks like Enya emerging from a blob of flesh.

I really dislike this, mckey is probably my least favourite winner (after whitney). The smile is really annoying and awkward, it looks like shes trying to blow air out her mouth whilst smiling at the same times.

Now that's just too much scrutiny on the photo. ^

Overrated, even though it's not horrible

she looks creepy and like a man

Looking back at this shot, I feel like she looks a little aged. They should've switched up her hairstyle and maybe edited out that smile line. That's really not her fault though, but I don't really like what she's giving. She's smirking so it just gives off a sort of "How u doin?" vibe.

she looks so old in this pic, and covergirl targets younger audience