I like the idea here and she looks great, but she definetely could have taken it MUCH farther
[Oct 02, 2008 at 11:05 PM]
this was not her best shot, the photographer and Jay said A LOT of great comments during the photoshoot, she surely did much better than this you can tell just by watching the episode.
eek, I don't like this shot. Have you guys noticed that Tyra was picking bad shots this week. I mean Mr. Jay would say they did really good, then the panel (besides Tyra) would not like the shots. Hence the bad feedback from Mckey's shot.
Given the cheesiness of the shoot (to me) I think she could have been really melodramatic in the poses and it would have expressed "heat wave" better than just laying there.
This isn't particularly standout, although it's still one of the lesser evils from this week. I'm just annoyed that Tyra deliberately chose a worse shot from Mckey's film. She should've chosen one of her better shots, despite their alleged ineffective portrayals of the heatwave theme. Mckey could then have received that critique instead. She totally seemed to have rocked the shoot too.
I like it. McKey cannot take a bad face shot. It's a good photo. The reason Tyra chose this picture is because it's the best of the ones that actually portray heat wave. She should not have done that.
Its obvious that Tyra picked the wrong shot. After all the praising Mr. Jay gave McKey, its sooo obvious. If Tyra said she picked this picture based on the story of "Overheat", she shouldve picked the other posed she did during the show (Jenah-like car stranded pose)
Tyra did say that there were better shots, but this was one of few that got the message across. I don't think it's fair to hate on Tyra, I beleive that she really cares for the girls and is truly invested in them. I agree with TaiOfMine. I'm not crazy about Mckey.
The bottom line is, if a model is hired to potray something, the client is more likely to use the shot that gets the story across as apposed to the shot where the model looks her best, so Tyra did the right thing imo.
I think she should have been called first. She won the challenge, looked great in judging and this picture is sooooooooo awesome. She looks stunning and collapsed
i think Mckey has many shoots better the this!.... cuz she did an amazing job on the photoshot and have extra shot's so she have many options of shot's to chosee, but even with that this is greaat!!!
The bottom line is, if a model is hired to potray something, the client is more likely to use the shot that gets the story across as apposed to the shot where the model looks her best, so Tyra did the right thing imo.