The Mckey ridiculous overrating is nothing new. I would have given the spot to Samantha, Analeigh, Marjorie, Elina, etc. All were pretty steady models and could work in the real world. Mckey never had to try and was praised the the point of ridiculousness. But THAT'S another story.
I don't really mind Mckey as the winner. Although I had my expectations really low considering the past two seasons, I thought she was consistently decent throughout the competition. Of course Tyra does have her favorites and does pick the wrong 'best' photos from week to week. Any of the girls that you mentioned I would have been happy with as well. (Although I think people get a little too crazy over Analeigh) But you do have to admit that on the go sees Mckey was very popular! Based on that evidence, the girl could book jobs.
honestly give it a rest now. she won. there is nothing you can do or say to change it. she looks like a model. isnt that what we've all been asking for. by no means were her pictures fabulous but for me at least her pictures have a very quirky beauty and each shots is portraying a story. her pictures completely take away the obvious perception of beauty, and that makes a model interesting